Thursday, August 12, 2010


I have recently been exposed to a national TV ad campaign urging viewers to pressure Congress to renew George W. Bush's tax cuts for the wealthy, first enacted in 2001 and 2003, which are due to expire at year's end. The ads feature conservative Republican former Senator and 2008 presidential candidate Fred Thompson as the spokesperson. He delivers his script in a reasoned and sober manner, but there is only one thing wrong with it. In this ad, Fred Thompson is lying to you. Deliberately, and with a flurry of bald-faced lies.

The ad is slick and well-produced. To those not knowing better, Thompson's delivery is convincing and rational. But it is a sham.

This deceptive monstrosity has been created by a shadowy far-right organization called The League of American Voters. The organization does not list its founders or donors, but it does claim to have many thousands of members. Clearly, it is very well funded to have produced and distributed an ad campaign of this magnitude.Its only listed officer is Bob Adams, who is listed as Executive Director. That this little bit of Karl Rovian-secrecy and sneakiness should be evidencing itself now as it did during the health care reform debate should not be surprising: Mr. Adams who served as a strategist for the conservative American Legislative Exchange Council during the George W. Bush administration. His current organization shares the very same address and suite number as another shadowy group, Americans for Tax Reform, which, according to the Senate's investigation of the Jack Abramoff sandal, served as a "conduit" for funds going from Abramoff's clients to finance phony grass-roots lobbying campaigns. There is also alleged overlap between these two groups and Tax Day Tea Party organizers.

This suspicious "League of American Voters" has been heard from before. During the health care reform debate, they prepared and tried to circulate a number of bogus scare ads against reform. Several of the major networks refused to air their ads, deeming them to be inaccurate and misleading. examined a number of those ads and found them to be "filled with misleading claims." But the networks haven't been as careful or conscientious with this current deceptive ad. I have seen it run on both ABC and CNN, and even MSNBC as well, and it has undoubtedly run on Fox "News" and others as well.

Below is the actual text of this current deceptive ad, delivered as it is by Fred Thompson, who should know better. I have inserted my refutations wherever applicable in bold, italicized type like this:

To a background of dark, somber music) "Folks, the American economy is struggling and Congress is about to make it a whole lot worse. Our nation faces a massive automatic tax increase at the end of this year when the Bush tax cuts expire. When that happens, your income taxes could increase by 10% or more." LIE! Taxes will increase ONLY for those making more than $250,00, exactly as President Obama campaigned and was elected on, and as he has been saying for the past two years! He and the Democratic leadership in Congress have stated numerous times that they wish to keep the tax cuts in place for ALL, except for the upper two income brackets which comprise a meager 5% of the population. Not only that, but CBS News reports that the wealthiest 0.7% of the population, those filing jointly earning more than $373,650, will only see an increase of 4.6% (from 35 to 39.6%), while those 1.2% of the population jointly filing with incomes from $209, 251 to $373,650 would see an increase of only 3%, from 33 to 36%. THAT IS A FAR CRY FROM THE 10% THOMPSON JUST LIED ABOUT!

"Capital gains taxes will jump over 30%. Taxes on dividends will more than double.It's not a pretty picture. Back in 2001, when these tax cuts were enacted, they helped jump-start the economy after 9/11, and if President Obama and Congress don't renew the Bush tax cuts, the effects will be devastating." Another LIE. Those Bush tax cuts did very little to jump-start the economy. The creation of millions of new, high-paying jobs was promised, but it never happened. Instead, major corporations shipped entire plants and millions of American jobs overseas to cheaper foreign labor markets in China, India, the Phillippines, Indonesia, Bangladesh, and Mexico. The only salaries that increased here were those of CEOs and their boards of directors, which skyrocketed while yours stayed the same or dropped. In fact, the tax-cutting administration of George W. Bush and Dick Cheney produced the FEWEST numbers of jobs here since that of Herbert Hoover!

"Recently, Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke urged Congress not to raise taxes, saying the economy is just too fragile." Another LIE. This is utter rubbish and all-out distortion, because that is not at all what Bernanke said. Instead, he said that extending the tax cuts would be "one way" to help the economy - but he also said the cuts should be offset, so as to not raise the deficit. HIS predecessor, Alan Greenspan, even echoed this belief by declaring the tax cuts should not be extended using unfunded, borrowed money, which is exactly what they would be if Congress followed Thompson's and the League of American Voters' urging.

"But taxes will increase automatically unless YOU act!I hope you will go to and sign the League of American Voters' petition. And call your Congressman and Senators and tell them to renew the Bush tax cuts. I'm Fred Thompson for the League of American Voters."

Fred Thompson and this League of American Liars should be ashamed for putting out such a dishonest and distorted piece of sophistry. This deliberate attempt to scare poor, working, and middle class Americans into thinking their taxes will shoot upward, just to get them to petition Congress to not raise the taxes of the nation's wealthiest 5%, is despicable and disgusting. As our nation's infrastructure crumbles and millions of ourr citizens find themselves unemployed or underemployed, here comes Fred Thompson and Bob Adams urging that the upper 5% not receive a VERY MILD TAX INCREASE and therefore not have to pay their fair share, a share THEY CAN EASILY AFFORD. These conservative Republicans and teabaggers who oppose taxing the rich should simply stop all their crying and moaning and take a look around them. Our wealthiest citizens are not at all "oppressed" by having a tax rate less than half of what others with similar incomes pay all across the globe! Extending these unfair and regressive Bush tax cuts will NOT create a single job, nor will it benefit in the least the other 95% of the population who really need help these days. Fred Thompson, we don't much care for snake oil salesmen---stop lying to us!



Tim said...

First yes Fred is a liar for sure. He has his own radio show and he's just like everyone else at Fox with lies.
Here's my fear, and perhaps you can talk me down from it... I think The great Appeaser (Obama) will cave on this. I think he'll extend the tax cuts for all. Possible for a year maybe two. It's been his MO to date.
I've lost my faith in the guy. We'll all go to bat for him and he'll leave us dangling in the wind yet again. I sure want to be wrong on this one.
btw nice reporting on this story.

Jack Jodell said...

Thanks, Tim. Thompson is a perfect example of today's far-right ideologue. He will say or do anything, without any scruples, to promote his agenda. Facts mean nothing to these people. They only care about their own ill-conceived notions. And they believe the more and the louder they tell a lie, the closer it comes to truth. With so many like Thompson running around, our mass perception of reality has hit a dangerous low.

TomCat said...

Welcome back, Jack!! As usualm you have delivered on what you promised at my place. As you said, iut dovetails perfectrly with what I wrote explaining who benefets, why heeping the tax cut for the poor and middle classes is economically stimulative and why keeping it for the rich is not.

On Tim's comment, we are better off if we all lose the tax cut than we are if the rich keep theirs. Even one year will cost $36 billion. If we all lose it we need to defuse the lie that Republicans will tell that Obama raised everyone's taxes. The only way that will happen is if Republicans block the extwensions for the poor and middle classes.

Jack Jodell said...

Thanks, TomCat. It is always inspiring to read your posts and comments, as they are always loaded with great facts, common sense, and basic decency. I can't see Obama caving on this one. The stakes are far too high, and he knows the Republicans will be slitting their throats by obstructing his plan and letting everyone's taxes go up across the board. Not even the Republicans are that damn stubborn or stupid!

Mycue23 said...

Fairly typical of the right wing in this country. If you yell the loudest then you win. It doesn't matter if what you say has no basis in fact. Facts have never mattered to that crowd. All they care about is what they can convince the low information voters of. And as we have seen, the LIV can be convinced of almost anything. The general public will once again be stirred up to campaign against their own self interest. This nonsense is never gonna end.

Jack Jodell said...

You've summed it up perfectly, my friend. But that's why it's so important for people like you and I to get our voices heard. If we can sway even one LIV, it was worth the trouble. Blog on, brother! :-)

mud_rake said...

Welcome back, Jack, and don't you leave no mor no mor!

The independent Joint Committee on Taxation came out last week with their analysis: the GOP plan to extend tax cuts will increase the deficit and benefit the rich.

Any further questions?

But as Tim said at the outset, The Great Appeaser may cave on this. If he does, he's go into my bottom desk drawer with all of the other cowards and scoundrels of history.

Jack Jodell said...

Thanks, and I hope both you and Tim are wrong on Obama. We so desperately need him to stand up right now!

Gwendolyn H. Barry said...

I agree Jack, Fred is lying. The lies are harming the economy too. As we fight, struggle to make things more balanced and to provide for our families' ... this dip shit and his ilk are out there purposely tearing down the community that makes up their constituency. Or as to application, half assed gov's or quitters. They are putting a hurting on the country.
Keep telling it. Keep saying so... like no body else, Professor.

Jack Jodell said...

I'm on it, Gwendolyn, just like you and the other good people who visit us are. We seem to have entered a particularly frantically insane cycle in right w9ng politics in this country. These are dangerous times we live in, but we shall prevail!

TRUTH 101 said...

Greed has no scruples. Fred was most likely paid a tidy sum for telling those whoppers. His presidential run was no more than a publicity ploy to get gigs like this.

You did touch on something I've observed and doesn't get the attention it should.

The shadow group that sponsored this sham claimed to have thousands of supporters. Of course none of them could be named. Much like conservative bloggers claim to get loads of emails from supporters even though they have comment sections on their blogs.

The right is not as vast member wise as they would have us believe. They do have big money to spread their lies and make it seem so though.

Jack Jodell said...

Truth 101,
You raise a very good point about the right's overstated numbers. When they, and people like Sarah Palin, Glenn Beck, and Michele Bachmann who epitomize them, make their wildly exaggerated claims, it gives proof of how deluded and obsessive they truly are. They have simply come to believe that the volume of their shouts is automatically converted into huge numbers. How wrong they are.

Energy Audit said...

America economy is struggling a lot. I was reading your post with full of interest. As the way you said that TV ads urge congress.

chennai female escorts said...

This post is looking very informative. The key point of this post is its valuable information. After reading this post any one will get some very important points which are only helpful even precious also. I use to visit the post of many different kinds but it is the first time when I am fully satisfied. Now a days people are in to the habit of making posts. I think it would be a good inspiration for them.

Anonymous said...

Why do you wack-os even bother. It's obvious you, like the other monkeys, are deaf, dumb and blind. Both parties have become compromised by power and personal greed, however, the obama/sanders nuts are so totally clueless it's pathetic. A report came out recently that 93% of the BS (barry sanders) "in crowd", have never held jobs outside of politics and education. That's horrifying!
If the nerds who suck up columns like this (kin to drinking bathwater) then move to France, Greece, Russia or China. Those nations should dole out enough Socialism or Communism for the lot of you. Try being independent thinkers for once, not haters.

Everblue Training Institution said...

We need to do all we can to get the economy back on its feet. We need to turn our attention to alternative energy sources and "going green" so we have the opportunity to have disagreements with politicians in the future.